Delaware Secretary of Education Dr. Susan Bunting informed the State Board of Education yesterday she had lunch with State Senator David Sokola and State Rep. Earl Jaques. As heads of the Senate and House Education Committee, Bunting said it was to discuss upcoming legislation. Could this lead to state takeover of school districts in Delaware? Continue reading
I truly thought Hillary Clinton was going to win yesterday. The thought of either of them winning didn’t sit well with me. But there is one key factor in this election that no one is talking about. Common Core. Those two toxic words that most states in this country wish they never adopted. In my state of Delaware, we are one of the many “blue” states that voted Clinton in. In looking at the maps, many of the states that have the Smarter Balanced Assessment and are considered to be big corporate education reform states voted for Hillary tonight.
Look at the states Hillary won that belong to the Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium: California, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, New Hampshire, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington. She lost other SBAC states like Idaho, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and West Virginia. I wouldn’t count those Hillary losses as “power players” in the corporate education reform movement. But many of the states she won are smack dab in the middle of it. Other states she won include other big “power players” such as Colorado, Illinois, Maine, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New Mexico, and New York. She lost Florida but that is Jeb Bush corporate education reform territory. Trump also won Tennessee but I attribute that victory more to this being a southern state. As of this writing, Michigan is still too close to call. While I have always seen corporate education reform as bi-partisan, many of the states that have been most affected by Common Core in the form of huge accountability stakes for standardized tests and horrible teacher evaluation systems based on those tests voted for the very same woman who didn’t say the words Common Core during her campaign.
Donald made it one of his campaign platforms that he would dump Common Core. Which would, by default, drastically change the very nature of state assessments but also the SAT which was revamped to the standards. While Hillary has gone on record stating that Common Core was poorly implemented, she never made it a part of her campaign. In fact, she didn’t make education a major part of her campaign at all. Which is ironic given how much of the corporate education reform movement she has been connected with. Especially through the Clinton Foundation. One of her first objectives once Bill Clinton became the Governor of Arkansas was to hold schools more “accountable” back in the 1980s. An accounting of this attempt at education reform in Arkansas was detailed in an article in Politico in April 2015.
But an article in The Weekly Standard showed me how very similar Hillary Clinton and Delaware Governor Jack Markell really are:
It’s clear from their statements at the time that the Clintons understood the importance of improving Arkansas schools. Bill Clinton argued that with factory jobs going overseas, the state could no longer rely on manufacturing and needed a more skilled workforce. But Arkansas students were scoring poorly on national exams.
That sounds almost exactly like the propaganda Delawareans have been subjected to by Markell. But Hillary Clinton’s education initiative began in 1983. Funny how the arguments for those who want greater accountability tend to blame it on low test scores and a need for a “skilled workforce”. Like many states since, Arkansas went through new tests over the years back then and the results were abysmal for students. As well, the Clintons wanted teachers to take skills tests to weed out the bad teachers. They never went ahead with this after the National Education Association refused to endorse Bill Clinton for Governor twice in the 1980s. Hillary made amends with the NEA when Bill ran for President in 1992 and they have fervently endorsed her ever since, much to the chagrin of their union members across the country.
The impossible happened tonight. The popular vote was tight, but the electoral map told a different tale. This is a new reality we will face in the next four years. It is what it is. On the plus side, I think we can safely rule out Jack Markell as the next United States Secretary of Education which was one of my greatest fears with Hillary winning. I imagine many Americans are freaking out right now. Trump is going to have to emerge from his past and transform himself if he ever wants any sense of credibility. His victory speech was very humble and he hit a lot of the right notes. I am still in complete and utter shock that I am writing the words President Trump.
At the end of a very long day stretching into the wee hours of a new day, part of me would like to think Trump’s promise of dumping Common Core resonated with many voters. But at the end of the day, Americans wanted change. At least over half of them did. The conversations Americans thought they would have today are vastly different.
Will a Trump presidency be able to put a halt to very destructive education policy that began in Arkansas during that very hot summer of 1983? When the parents of today’s students were still in school? Before some of them were even born? Will it end the long saga that kicked into high gear with the 1992 “Dear Hillary” letter from Marc Tucker? This is something I would very much like to talk to Donald Trump about. And you better believe every single state Department of Education is going to be scrambling on their Every Student Succeeds Act drafts tomorrow. Sometimes you just have to find the silver lining in things.
At 9am this morning, Delaware Governor Jack Markell will sign an Executive Order to promote stakeholder engagement for the Every Student Succeeds Act. The event, taking place at Lewis Elementary School in Wilmington, will deal with the state plan for ESSA. Each state in the country must submit a plan for how they will carry out ESSA.
I have to admit I’m very curious to see what this Executive Order will be. I find it ironic Markell would sign something mandatory like this. Markell got a ton of stakeholder engagement during the House Bill 50/Opt Out saga. He didn’t listen then, and I see no sign of him listening to anyone now. He still hasn’t signed House Bill 399, dealing with teacher evaluations. This would have been the perfect place for him to do it. I have to doubt this will either be something very benign and won’t mean anything or he is up to something.
The State Board of Education in Arkansas issued a press release last week calling for more participation in planning around their state accountability system. The last time Delaware tried something similar it met with a great deal of controversy because of a lack of stakeholders. Come back later today for a recap of what Markell is planning.