History will teach us nothing. Or that’s what they say. In this case, history is teaching us everything. Almost three and a half years ago, Newark Charter School had a major modification approved that allowed them to open a high school. One of the biggest concerns was the financial impact it would have on Christina School District.
During the Public Hearing for their modification request, NCS Board President Steve Dressel said the financial impact of $2.4 million wouldn’t hit Christina until year five of their expansion.
While CSD will make the claim that an NCS expansion will be “devastating”, the reality is the financial impact on CSD is quite small. CSD estimated it to be $2.4 million…
Dressel was correct in one aspect. That estimation was “quite small” because when you flash forward three years later, that number jumped three times the original estimate. In their final budget for FY2016, Christina had a picture in the presentation which showed how much Newark Charter School and other charters receive from them.
Christina had 2,008 students choice out of the district to Newark Charter School. On the Delaware DOE website, it shows NCS had 2,140 students enrolled. That means nearly 94% of their students come from Christina. And that number will go up for both this year as NCS reaches a 12th grade. How do charter payments, which were estimated at $2.4 million three years ago, jump up to $7.3 million? And counting? Did the formula go up that much in just three years? Are we sure this formula hasn’t changed already without anyone knowing? This is a huge financial impact for a school district. This illustrates that NCS knows exactly what kind of impact this has when they get their checks from Christina. And still, they want more.
While some called my article the other day a call for a “holy war” against charters, it was Greg Meece who once said “this is jihad against charter schools,” when the Delaware State Education Association commissioned a report on the impact charter schools have on school districts. This came from a 2008 article in the News Journal. Ironically enough, David Blowman talked about the impact this had on the Brandywine School District to the tune of $2.3 million going to charter schools. Blowman was the key figure in the now-failed attempt at changing the local cost per pupil formula which would give charter schools more money.
At the time of this article, legislation was brought forth to have the State Board of Education limit the number of new charter school applications if it would have a large financial impact on the districts the charters drew their students from. The bill did not move forward in that session, but Meece’s claims of destruction to Delaware charter schools hardly came to pass. The report DSEA bought was released to the press by former State Senator Charlie Copeland. Copeland later opened up a charter school called Delaware Academy of Public Safety & Security.
I believe history will repeat itself if this new charter funding formula goes ahead at some point. This scenario has been proven time and time again throughout America over the years. The price tag keeps getting higher and higher every year. Even though there was a moratorium on new charters in New Castle County last year, that didn’t stop the State Board of Education from approving many modifications for increased enrollment at some charters. With all the increases, that might as well have been a new charter school. But our State Board of Education, led by an Executive Director who is definitely in bed with the Delaware Charter Schools Network, keeps remaining oblivious to the reality before them.
But Meece, drawing from his infamous “crab bucket” analogy from 2012, still seems to think everyone is out to destroy his “successful” school. Christina is not paying them what they deserve and they want more! Regardless of the consequences. The original opinion piece by Meece is no longer available from the News Journal, but luckily Delaware Liberal saved it for all to see:
Years ago, someone explained to me a phenomenon called the “crab bucket syndrome.” As crabs are caught and tossed into a bucket, the first crab tries to climb out to save its life. Other crabs, seeing his escape plan, grab hold of the first crab’s legs, which pulls him back into the bucket. Eventually, all the crabs perish. In schools, this is a metaphor for, “If I can’t have it, neither can you.” This is what happens when a group tries to “pull down” any other school that shows success can be achieved. This is happening in Newark, where a group is trying to stop one of our most successful public schools, Newark Charter School, from expanding.
As Pandora brilliantly pointed out in her article on this, Meece forgets about all the crabs that are killed so the few can get out as well as the fact that Meece’s actions are what happened to Christina not Newark Charter School. For Christina, the tipping point with Newark Charter School happened three years ago. Now it is just the spear point jabbing at an already bleeding wound.
2 thoughts on “The Heart of the District/Charter Funding War”