I attended the first half of the Delaware Education Funding Task Force meeting tonight. After Delaware Governor Jack Markell gave some brief opening comments thanking the members of the committee for their hard work, he advised them this isn’t an easy task force. As he was leaving, he made a point to greet and shake hands with everyone in the room. And I mean everyone!
Members trickled in so the meeting didn’t start until about 5:20. There are some very vocal members on this committee with very strong ideologies. The bad part is when many of them are different. I have no clue how this group is going to come to a consensus in the next couple months. I saw members on this task force who belong to the General Assembly (who listened for the most part), DOE, State Board, the traditional districts, the charter crowd, Rodel, school boards, the business community, Delaware PTA, GACEC, and advocates for ELL students.
Donna Johnson from the State Board of Education did make it a point to talk about the group’s discussions about basic special education funding for students in Kindergarten to 3rd grade. I do recall seeing a potential funding model where funds were reallocated in the needs-based funding formula for the state. But this shouldn’t even be a topic of conversation for an education funding task force. Put House Bill 30 up for a full vote and get it done. It’s what, $11.5 million to fund that bill? Make it happen. Maybe the DOE can get rid of a ton of their vendor contracts and their non-vendor paychecks for all these people who show up on Delaware Online Checkbook with no transparency surrounding these payments whatsoever. After all, the DOE were the ones that torpedoed this funding when the topic first came up six years ago.
It was interesting hearing some members talk about the lack of authority for a school principal to make funding decisions. This was more from the charter side of the equation. But members on the other side disagreed, saying they have the authority based on the pool of money they get from the district. One member said even if they do find the right number or formula for funding, how do you audit that? Does that money allocated as extra support for low-income and ELL students mean reduced classroom sizes or more teachers? Some members felt that because 41 states have successful funding formulas that will translate as success for Delaware. But how is that success measured? By standardized tests? Graduation rates? Will they have pilot schools or districts to try it out? What does low-income and poverty mean in terms of percentage of students? Since the state changed how they measure poverty, but the DOE goes by one thing and DHHS goes by another, which is right? If the group doesn’t necessarily agree with the WEIC funding formulas, what does that mean for the General Assembly when they vote on the redistricting in Wilmington? If the majority of the group believes changing property assessments is the way to go what does that mean for the property owners who have no voice on this committee? We should do what California does and vote on propositions like this. Then we will see where the real voting power exists!
There were people at this meeting who I have never seen face to face but I have written about them a bit. One as recently as last Thursday. I had to pick up some groceries and my son REALLY wanted Dairy Queen so I snuck out while the group was on their pizza break. I wished I could have stayed, but family first! I am very curious what comes out of the final report.
4 thoughts on “My Observations From The Education Funding Task Force Meeting Tonight”
Family is always first! Something I believe our society has forgotten….
Interesting. I’d like to hear more about the people who were there.
Excellent question Kavips, this is the membership list:
Two Members of the Senate
Senator David Sokola
Senator Gary Simpson
Two Members of the House
Representative Earl Jaques
Representative Ruth Briggs-King
Michael Jackson – Deputy Controller General
Secretary of Education
David Blowman, Deputy Secretary, Department of Education
Director of Office of Management and Budget
Brian Maxwell, Deputy Director, OMB
President of the Delaware State Board of Education
Governor’s Education Policy Advisor
President of the Delaware State Education Association
Parent, appointed by Delaware Parent Teacher Association
One Superintendent, appointed by the President of the Chief School Officers Association
Heath Chasanov, Superintendent, Woodbridge School District
One Superintendent of a Vocational Technical District appointed by President of the Chief School Officers Association
Vicki Gehrt, Superintendent, New Castle County Vocational Technical District
One traditional public school administration employed at school with high population of at risk students, appointed by the Delaware Association of School Administrators
One charter school leader employed at school with high population of at risk students, appointed by the Delaware Charter Schools Network
One local school board member, appointed by the Delaware School Board Association
Council Chair of the Governor’s Advisory Council for Exceptional Citizens
One business representative, appointed by the Governor
One member of a community organization serving students in poverty, appointed by the Governor
Ray Jones Avery
One member of a community organization serving students learning English
Three community members with special knowledge of education finance or special ability to contribute to discussion, appointed by Governor
Obviously, Barbara Rutt is not the President of the State Board of Education, and Lindsay O’Mara’s replacement is Meghan Wallace. Wendy Strauss sat in for Robert Overmiller from GACEC since they had their meeting last night as well. I didn’t see Senator Simpson or State Rep. Briggs-King there. State reps. Kim Williams and Paul Baumbach were in the crowd, as well as Bill Doolittle (Delaware PTA, GACEC).