Publius, a frequent commenter on Kilroy’s Delaware, commented about advocacy for the students of Delaware. In an attempt to demean those who promote equity in our schools, Publius broke down advocates into the following categories: special needs, low-income, English Language learners, orderly school environments, super-rigorous school environments, intelligently differentiated schools, and intelligently intra-school differentiated programs. While he was mainly talking about the difference between choice schools and traditional schools, this isn’t the first time Publius has used such phrases. While many know who Publius is, including myself, most of us can only laugh at his terminology.
But this comment was a bit different and shows the true thinking of someone who truly believes that students who are “smarter” should be separated from those who are not. Such thought created the Charter School of Wilmington. While some truly believe a school like this is justified in their enrollment preferences, public thought has shifted away from this narrow early 20th Century viewpoint to something more akin to the more modern and rational thoughts around equity and equality.
In the 1930s, Adolph Hitler rose to power because he responded to the fears of the Germans. By promoting the “Aryan” ideal, Hitler was able to amass an incredible amount of power that allowed him to essentially take over mainland Europe. As a result of Hitler’s obsession with this master race, tens of millions of people died in a war that changed the face of the world. In Nazi Germany’s Civil Service Law, citizens of Germany had to be able to provide documentation that they belonged to the “true” Aryan race, which was mainly Nordic in design. Those who were not part of this very select “race” were considered subhuman, or untermenschen.
Publius, through his words, truly believes the “strong” should be separated from the “weak”. He doesn’t use those words, but instead crafts them into such words as “intelligently differentiated”, “talented and gifted”, “orderly”, and “imperatives”. But at the same time, he wants to be included in all the conversations concerning the problems with Delaware schools:
Assume that everyone in the dialogue is in good faith and has an honest reason for their views. If the current environment of attack-vilification persists, then we will get nowhere.
What Publius doesn’t understand is why so many people can’t wrap their head around his century old untermenschen ideals. He has his defenders over on Kilroy’s, but none go to the lengths he does to justify his comments. It is extremely hard to have a “conversation” with someone who is so clearly elitist and discriminatory. I don’t believe Publius even sees this. He doesn’t realize how his words actually harm charter schools in Delaware. As the Delaware blogosphere’s largest proponent of school choice and charter schools, he does far more harm than good. But because he is “that voice”, that advocate, we have to wonder if the stereotype of charter schools is actually based on what he says. Such views led to the slaughter of over six million Jews in World War II. While I certainly don’t believe Publius would even remotely come close to advocating such options for those who are different, his words could affect those who do. There are people in the world today, even in Delaware, who believe in the righteousness of such atrocities. Situations like this plant the seeds in others to do vile and abhorrent deeds.
But Publius also takes pride in describing others on Kilroy’s Delaware, including myself!
Little Kevin: Despite your striving, you are not “why we fight”
“The People” choose the public will. Not what The Governor tells them to think. Not what a blogger tells them what to think. Especially not a blogger from Dover with no cattle but with a shopworn ballcap.
Notice how he refers to me as “little”. As well he specifically refers to me as being “from Dover” as if Dover is subpar to where he comes from. He also seems to think those who live in Dover must be agrarian in nature but I have “no cattle”. As well, for someone who has never seen me with a “shopworn ballcap”, I also have to wonder how he feels about people who wear baseball hats. Even more frightening, in looking at my Facebook pictures and other pictures that appear of myself on social media and search engines, the only pictures out there of me with a baseball hat on are from twenty years ago. That was during my senior year Spring Break when myself and several others spent a week in West Virginia helping out the poor and unfortunate. Is Publius actually stalking me? I do wear a “shopworn ballcap” when I mow my lawn or do other outside work. But Publius would only know that if he happened to be in my neighborhood which I don’t even remotely see as a possibility knowing his identity. Disturbing or a stereotype? You be the judge!
To be completely fair, I have gone after Publius many times in reaction to things he has said. I have called him a “little man” and racist on more than one occasion. I’m sure those who know Publius and ask him about these things would get a jovial laugh from him and would come back and tell me not to take him seriously. But words like “intelligently differentiated” disturb me on many levels. It is very demeaning to a lot of people, but most of all parents of children with special needs. Parents of children with Down’s Syndrome or other cognitive disorders should be offended by these discriminatory comments.
There are a plethora of other issues with charter schools, but nothing gets the conversation going more than talk about enrollment preferences and counseling out of “troubled” students. Even Charter School of Wilmington is slowly coming around to this based on their recent board agenda. There was a discussion topic listed as “increasing low income and special ed applications”. Earlier this week, I helped a six year old girl with disabilities get into Newark Charter School’s Kindergarten lottery despite a ridiculous application policy the school’s board made last September.
As more and more Delaware citizens come around more and more to a greater weight for civil rights over enrollment preferences, we see those like Publius fighting even harder for their warped ideals and ideologies. Despite all of this, I hope the day comes when Publius can see the error of his ways and embrace equality and equity.
10 thoughts on “The “Intelligently Differentiated” Untermenschen Schools Of Delaware”
Nazis? Really? I agree with you on a lot of stuff but this comparison is beneath you.
Unless you have followed Publius for years on Kilroy’s Delaware like I have, it may be hard for to understand the reasoning behind this. I am not the only one who feels this way as well!
No, sorry. That’s an ugly, ugly comparison that has no place here (or anywhere).
When you are talking about student placement and where they should be and not be, and those who are intelligent-smart and intelligent-not smart, there are comparisons to the line of thought behind many of the Nazi ideals. Like I said in the article, I highly doubt that’s where Publius is going with this, but the vitriol coming from people like him could certainly feed the thoughts that can and do exist in some people. I agree it is a very ugly comparison, but for the reasons I just stated, I wrote about it.
Suit yourself. I’ve expressed my opinion
Kevin made intellectual comparisons to the ideals of Hitler and his followers and spoke to the dangers these mindsets can present. Nothing he said in this article was demeaning or personally derogatory to Publius. The term “intellectually differentiated” makes me nauseous. I am a mom who was told to abort my daughter because she would be intellectually challenged and not have the same quality of life as a child without an extra chromosome. I would wish that people would be more offended Publius used that phrase and suggests separating by intelligence than the fact Kevin mentioned history. It’s an ugly part of history people want to forget but it happened and “the people” allowed it to happen because they did not take note of the subtle messages when they started. My daughter has the same right to education and encouraging towards success as any charter school student. Publius should meet families, like mine, rather than planning on sending children, like my daughter, to subpar schools so they do not detract from the education of the “talented and gifted” population.
AESABO, some people just are not intelligent enough to understand the true genius that Kevin actually is.
Kevin, I mean that wholeheartedly. That was by no means, meant to be sarcastic. I truly believe that you are gifted.
Publius is a fraud. Supports choice with zealotry, but when that choice is to opt out of a test, he devolves into a rabid hypocrite on the issue.
AESABO, I appreciate your story and thanks for sharing it. However, I need to point out the reason Kevin’s post is so objectionable has nothing to do with it being insulting to Publius (I couldn’t care less what’s insulting to Publius). It’s objectionable because it’s disrespectful to the memory of the victims of the Holocaust.
Whenever you feel like confirming Godwin’s Law, it’s probably best to lie down until the feeling goes away.
Godwin’s Law is not official law. It can also be used as an excuse. It also has been used in ways to attempt to end a comparison that has valid points to it. Of course, it is all opinion, but Godwin’s Law is in and of itself a form of censorship.